The rubber is pretty soft, you should be able to just put a set of slip joint pliers on the base and give it a twist. I'd be surprised if any tooth marks don't go away in a day or less.
You can also get smooth jaw pliers. I've got a set of channel locks st work with smooth Jaws for use on plated nuts. Prevents marring the surface.
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk